Some readers would possibly reply to my query with a query: Why am I stunned? The appropriate has all the time been infested with racists and bigots, you would possibly argue. But whereas I freely acknowledge that there was extra racism on the suitable than I used to be keen or in a position to see earlier than the rise of Trump, there was a definite change in younger right-wing tradition. It’s dramatically completely different from what it was after I was in school, in legislation college and beginning my authorized profession.
As I survey the suitable — particularly the younger, so-called new proper — I see a motion within the grip of some fairly easy however highly effective cultural forces. Hatred, mixed with masculine insecurity and cowardice, is herding younger right-wing males into outright bigotry and prejudice. Opposite to their self-conception, they’re not sturdy or robust or brave. They’re timid sheep in wolves’ clothes, transferring precisely the place the loudest and most aggressive voices inform them to.
To grasp the cultural dynamic, I need to introduce you to an obscure on-line idea, no enemies to the suitable. A tiny fringe adopts this mind-set as a aware ethos, however for a a lot bigger group, it’s merely their cultural actuality. Of their minds, the left is so evil — and represents such an existential menace — that any lodging of it (or any criticism of the suitable) undermines the forces of sunshine of their nice battle in opposition to the forces of darkness. Assault the left in essentially the most searing phrases, and also you’ll benefit from the thunderous applause of your friends. Criticize the brand new proper, and you may expertise a vicious backlash. The result’s a relentless pull to the extremes.
Actually, certainly one of their prime reproofs of what they may name the zombie proper, the Reagan proper of their mother and father’ technology, is that it was just too accommodating. As they see it, classical liberal politics, which protect free speech and sturdy debate as a precedence, emboldened and empowered the left. Compromise, of their view, ran just one manner, and conservatism conserved nothing. The left, of their thoughts, is successful the tradition battle in a rout.
And right here’s the place masculine insecurity enters the equation. To the brand new proper, their opposition to the left is so clearly appropriate that solely ethical cowardice or monetary opportunism (“grifting”) can clarify any compromise. To combat on the suitable — primarily by trolling on social media or embracing authoritarianism because the based mostly various to weak-kneed classical liberalism — is seen as sturdy, brave and funky. It’s an indication of a fierce and unbiased thoughts.